How Quality Review and Heatmaps Can Reduce Remediation Time, Cost, and Effort for an Acquired Trial Master File

Posted by Karen Roy and Sarah Tucker | May 2, 2022 10:59:39 AM

Adapted from a Phlexglobal Ask An Expert interactive discussion, “How to Ensure TMF Inspection Readiness & Compliance for a Recently Acquired Product,” held March 2, 2022 and available on-demand here. Third in a series; you can read the first blog - “Why Is the Trial Master File Critical in M&A Activities?” – here and the second blog – “Congratulations! You Just Acquired a Trial Master File. Now What?” – here. 


As mentioned before in this blog series, an acquired Trial Master File (TMF) requires special attention to ensure that essential content is available, documented, and organized appropriately. A deeper analysis of the TMF and its components is likely necessary to ensure inspection-readiness. However, the analysis should provide tactical and strategic insights so your team can reflect on it, take action, and communicate the strategies and remediation plans to management and other functional areas within your organization.    

Phlexglobal recommends two expert methodologies and tools that help TMF owners establish the current state of the TMF, and better understand what steps are needed to maintain compliance: TMF Quality Review and TMF Heatmaps.   

TMF Quality Review: Expert Insight Improves Inspection-Readiness  

A TMF Quality Review is a comprehensive evaluation providing critical details on the quality, completeness, and timeliness of the Trial Master File. It includes a complete inventory of all content, line-by-line details for all required actions, and a comprehensive gap analysis identifying missing documentation.  

An effective TMF Quality Review should: 

  • Be conducted by experienced TMF practitioners who can bring deep understanding of current inspection standards at health authorities  
  • Include documents and data from ANY relevant source, whether paper, shared online folders, disk drives, a dedicated eTMF system – or some combination of these 
  • Incorporate risk-based assessments to quickly pinpoint and drill down to problem areas 
  • Provide meaningful and pragmatic insights, together with detailed, expert recommendations for any necessary remediation 

If required, an expert TMF Quality Review should also have the flexibility to be conducted on a wider scale across multiple studies, to provide broader, portfolio-level visibility into the health and current state of TMF assets.  

TMF Heatmaps: A Visual Guide to TMF Health 

TMF Heatmaps offer a snapshot view of where documents may be missing in the study. They contain visual and textual overviews of TMF findings and help identify recurring patterns as well as major and minor areas that should be addressed. Heatmaps are valuable tools for managing and communicating the rationale and priorities for remediation strategies. For example, if there were patients in one country where entire sections of the TMF are missing, the visual insights help teams quickly identify the issue and initiate conversations to track down missing documents and data.  

Heatmaps offer practical insights regarding the actions necessary to improve TMF health and inspection-readiness. For example, logic checks and cross-checks validate the quality of individual documents and whether documents all relate to each other properly.  

Issues by severity

To be effective, a TMF Quality Review should include visualizations such as heatmaps to guide risk mitigation. This includes root cause analysis as well as recommended corrective actions such as TMF structure refinement, clarification of document expectations, or SOP changes. For example, by mapping Artifact Impact Level against Error Category Severity, you can prioritize efforts around the highest risk and impact.

TMF Views and Insights 

TMF Quality Review and TMF Heatmaps offer unprecedented transparency into the overall health of the Trial Master File, while offering a roadmap to improve TMF compliance. These advanced tools have been rigorously used and proven to turn poor-quality Trial Master Files into inspection-ready assets.  


Need help or have questions about an acquired a Trial Master File? Request a complimentary assessment from one of our TMF experts today.

Want more on this topic?  

Topics: TMF

Entering the Post-Paper Realism: The Principles of Cyber Ethics

The Shoulds and Shouldn’ts of Electronic Systems and Data in Clinical Trials Intro

Read More

Overcoming TMF misfiles and metadata errors to reduce inspection risk

Trial master file misfiles are a common occurrence, with as many as one in every 10 documents being misfiled.  

Read More

TMF Management in Clinical Trials Blog 2: The Path to Metric Nirvana

Good morning, good afternoon, good evening (I like to cover every possibility because who knows when you are reading ...

Read More

TMF Management in Clinical Trials Blog 1: The Simple Process

And we are back with another season of blogs guys, I know you missed my ramblings after the Clinical Trials and TMF 101 ...

Read More

Clinical Trials & the TMF 101 - Blog 4: The TMF Trinity

Introduction We have been on a journey you and me, we started off by understanding the purpose of a clinical trial and ...

Read More

Subscribe To Our Blog!

Digital Brain Header Large Brain Right

It's time to raise your standard 

Contact Us